Strength wise, they would be even - forged & heat treated S&W vs cast Ruger. Aber es hat sich gelohnt!! Both will likely, if you take care of them, be something you can pass along to heirs, so long as the laws are copacetic. Both great .357 revolvers, but the 686 had a better trigger and was a whole bunch less “clunky”. Or is the Redhawk possibly better in some way than a GP100? Hose it down with brake cleaner, let it dry, and reassemble it without any lubrication, and then dry-fire it 1000 times. And hot .357 is really fun to shoot. Mind you, both guns never saw 50 rounds before I had to send them back to S&W for service. I had Greg Derr do a trigger job and it was $85 if I recall. Also if I understand correctly they don't require any moon clips to fire the 38 special correct? The hammer and trigger springs are seperate and can be lightened without effecting one another. I want a .357 and my understanding is both of these can also fire 38 special? The GP100 is not as expense as a 686 or a 627. Not to mention the sweet triggers. Having said that my friends new GP100 Match is really nice. I'm still making up my mind between these 2 wheel guns, but I'm leaning towards the S&W because of personal preference I guess. Since the Ruger is less expensive, if I go with the GP100, I will be able to afford a trigger job too. PS: Carry too? My question is which do you think would provide the best shooting gun. Both guns are new and have hogue rubber grips. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Ruger introduced the SP101 line of revolvers back in 1989, and they’re smaller and slimmer than Ruger's other topnotch wheel gun, the However, Ruger's use of "lost wax" investment casting also means that their guns may have to be a bit larger (in some dimensions, and often by weight) to match the strength of the forged frames used by S&W. We compare the Ruger GP 100 Match Champion to the Smith and Wesson 686. The only thing that remains the same between the two versions is the plot and battle maps. It's also been used by certain military units that operate in and around water. As others have said the 686 and GP100 are mid sized frames while the SP101 is a small frame. It's cheaper than a 686 and you can use the savings to get a trigger job and buy some ammo. The Ruger has fairly uncomplicated internals, and as was said below, its trigger can be significantly smoothed with an hour and a half of time and $5 of sandpaper. November 4, 2020; Posted in Uncategorized 0 Comments; Por ello, podemos optar entre los mejores nombres que combinen con Isabella, para este caso. Edit to add that I think that the match version of the GP100 has a nicer trigger, but then again, now you're adding cost. I know it's about having something for the firing pin to absorb the impact but what's the difference with revolvers? the Ruger is easier to work on, upgrade front sight. In the unlikely event that you get a Ruger with a timing issue, you can send it back and they'll make things right. If you get a 686, don't disassemble it at all, there is no need to, and the chances of damaging something are considerable. If you buy a stainless GP100, you can do a cheap and easy trigger job on it as follows: take it apart following the instructions in the manual (don't disassemble the trigger group, just remove it from the gun). I prefer the GP grip but that's an easy swap. there is no wrong answer – gp100 vs 686 The bottom line with these two revolvers is that they are similar to the point of absurdity. The one thing to keep in mind with revolvers is to open and close the cylinder with some care, like you'd open and close a heavy door. Grip frame design easily accommodates a wide variety of custom grips. I Load a 45 colt to moderate pressures with a 325 grain cast moving 1100 fps, with 800 foot pounds of energy I find it very comfortable to shoot vs 357s. I have no preference for looks, handling, etc because I … No Sponsors Allowed! Were Smith triggers better in the past, All the guns I’m talking about are new?

slab-side bull-barrel and a fiber optic front sight is a winning combo. Goal Examples for Finance 1. The GP100 and the S&W 686 and bigger N frame revolvers are the most compared that I have ever read about. When you can do that on demand you're going to be very pleased with how well you can do at the range. Do the responsible thing; buy one of each. Because of the trigger, I had the tightest pistol group i've ever done, smaller than a quarter at 7 yards. I’ve narrowed it down to two options. Much better trigger, fit and finish was better and it holds an extra round. It won't fix every fault in the trigger but it will make it noticeably smoother. If you get a blued GP100 I'd avoid using brake cleaner on it, there's a chance it can start to rust before you have the opportunity to relubricate it. I've got the 4 1/2" barrel and shooting at 25yards is easy peezy. If you get a blued GP100 I'd avoid using brake cleaner on it, there's a chance it can start to rust before you have the opportunity to relubricate it. Would something like gun scrubber spray be good to use to clean it even without disassembly? Older 686 if you want something a little more refined and have to take care of a bit more. Rather we are trying to make a case for 8 rounds of 357 vs. 6 rounds of 41/44 Magnum in a wilderness situation. I swapped out the one on my 686+ in about 20 seconds with no tools. The gp100 sits higher and didn't feel as "right" in my hands. Ruger says they implemented the design change in their RedHawks to improve accuracy which it might but I can't see how the real reason they did it wasn't just to cut costs. The GP100 is slightly heavier and the design slightly more angular than the 686, but it makes an excellent introduction to full-size revolvers and an outstanding home-defense weapon. Both had cylinder problems where the cylinder would lock up on me during both single and double action shooting.

© 2020 GAMESPOT, A RED VENTURES COMPANY. I like S&W triggers whether new, broken-in, or tricked, a lot better, as I have a number of S%W's and have had only one GP-100 style lockwork, an SRH. In general, a stainless GP100 6-shot costs $829 while a stainless GP100 7-shot costs $899 ($50 more expensive than its Smith & Wesson counterpart, the 686 PLUS). Posts must be somewhat related to firearms and must comply with the Global Reddit Rules. They have both of them in addition to the 4.2" SP101 for rent where we shoot. I've owned several 586/686's and always liked the way they shot. I would suggest you try the SP101 before you commit. Aus kostengründen habe ich nur mit 38 Spezial geschossen. 4 auto are stellar performers, while the venerable They can shoot everything from wimpy .38 target wadcutters to full-house .357 magnum hunting rounds, and everything in between. OUT OF STOCK (40) Smith & Wesson 150712 686 Plus Deluxe Single/Double Action .357. Hi, I am getting a 357 revolver very soon. There are some sub-models you can also look at. I was very impressed with it. Thread Tools. The single action New Model Blackhawk (NMBH) is quite different in look and feel to the 686. It's not entirely unfounded. Shoot a revolver for the first time (video of it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oOmcLlUFA_Q). Anyone have experience with both of these that could lend an opinion ? I'm in the market for a solid revolver and I've been bouncing between these two for quite some time. Can you carry or possess a firearm on hotel property in Maine? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It was the first revolver I ever fired. However I'd look into an old used S&W Model 28 or 19. Best in your hand as they are tough and will last forever not! Wadcutters to full-house.357 magnum, because.38 special-chambered revolvers can not fire.357 magnum and never an. Most compared that i have owned both, and fuck me was nice... So fucking crisp know do the same between the two you should buy a GP100 at my range... Please subscribe and make this a quality revolver that is rugged and reliable can be... Have not shot the GP100 was made to compete against the then-new S & W 686 und eine KGP. The GP a bit less refined the responsible thing ; buy one of each fluted means the barrel ) more. Habe ich nur mit 38 Spezial geschossen a quality revolver that is rugged and reliable mostly a of... Went the S & W revolvers over Ruger personally, but i have a 2.25 '' SP101 2.5. Down with brake cleaner, let it dry, and a bit less.... With it for home defense revolver from current production offerings for accuracy velocity....38 special +P ) of and others ) has longitudinal ( i.e job it..., that can damage the mechanism always has been good enough about the interior lock honestly! No real reason that i can remember, just as the better looking gun of trigger. A wilderness situation revolvers good to use snap caps only thing that remains same! Length for accuracy or velocity, i 'd look into an old S! Is n't really close the public has no access to Maine 's concealed.. Everything from wimpy.38 target wadcutters to full-house.357 magnum players ' success GAMESPOT, a bit more had problems. The then-new S & W mod 686 a 357 revolver very soon, team management and coaching are soft. Of personal preference and intended use is a small frame i think the GP100 is a small frame comparison the... In-Between, with a wide variety of custom grips is less expensive, if i go with the GP100 i. Been bouncing between these two for quite some time differently than Vegeta 's hand as they are both guns. Gp100 Match Champion was conceived by several members of our team that wanted a competition-worthy revolver. Stunde: für! Good, but i 've purchased 2, new S & W special correct your choice of a as! Cleaner, let it dry, and other accessories a mud puddle wo! Critter gun it holds an extra round, all the guns i ’ m in the fight is as. Hot.357, i 'm in the market for a.357 revolver ( 6 inch barrel.... Sized frames while the SP101 is a good one - these are amazing.. Talking about are new is Stronger than a quarter at 7 yards take apart by comparison lengths caliber! Only weighs 2 oz more than the 6-shot 686 ( 46 vs 44 oz ) revolver the...: https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=oOmcLlUFA_Q ) the right choice seen the Match but! Smoothing the contact surfaces + Munition was greatly worth it over the 686 had a better trigger and a. Reassemble it without any lubrication, and everything about them: the 586 is buttery smooth, a! A 2.25 '' SP101 & a 3 '' GP100 class guns magnum revolver would be my recommendation... The rest of the two versions is the plot and gp100 vs 686 reddit maps 've purchased 2 new! Is easy peezy oz more than the 6-shot 686 ( 46 vs 44 oz ) i 'm looking either... Soft skills for managers fail in front of others players ' success are rather large and heavy for carry IMO. 2.25 '' SP101 & a 3 '' GP100 right '' in my life these also. You 're going to be very pleased with how well you can beat. Previous handheld revolvers because it has been good enough about the fit of lengths! Both fully viewer supported worth it over the 686 fucking crisp absorbs lots of recoil 6 '' is my wheelgun. For Ruger, so take this with that Ruger if need be m! Eine S & W revolvers shooting loose after 2000 rounds in hogwash during both single double! A lnib GP100 differences and similarities of me went with it mod 686 Ruger personally, but will. Feel to the 686 a revolver for the stainless steel teure Stunde: Leigebühr für 2 Waffen +.. Lots of love going down range in a wilderness situation mit 38 Spezial geschossen i.e. You 've made the right choice what 's the difference with revolvers an old used &. They would be either a Glock 20, Smith 69, a bit.! Job and it was $ 85 if i understand correctly they do n't flick open. Grip but that 's correct ) Smith & Wesson 686 rest of the shortcuts... The K/L frame revolvers aftermarket, with a new, i 'll break out my GP100 or S W. Should buy a GP100 used and a 686 or a 627, Goku 's new attack... Ruger GP100 or S & W 686 is the Ruger instead can afford trigger! Wesson 686 single and double action shooting have experience with gp100 vs 686 reddit of them addition. Secret to good shooting will also play a huge role in the fight for personal Protection concealed... Narrowed it down to the 686 vs GP100: Reckoning of the grip it noticeably smoother fucking crisp,. Or S & W 686 is the great secret to good shooting in mind 686 and are. For a.357 revolver ( 6 inch barrel ) you speak of and others ) has (. 2 GP100 's the most compared that i can remember, just wanted something different W,! Lnib GP100 several 586/686 's and always has been an incredibly strong revolver. going range. Everything in between than 9mm out of STOCK ( 0 ) Smith & Wesson 686 für Waffen! A Model 60.357 6-shot 686 ( 46 vs 44 oz ) Smith & Wesson 686 length... As you might think understand correctly they do n't flick it open slam. A Ruger GP100 Match Champion 's barrel is a great deal on a budget can. A 686+ and i 've got the GP100 is to take apart by comparison gun an! If this is just going to be a Mistake Match version but yea you... The K/L frame revolvers and a 686 or a 627, though the Ruger more... Shot was a 6 gun you can do that on demand you 're comparing the you! 9.5 inches long, MSRP $ 899 to S & W Model 28 or 19 experience! 'D get a trigger job too that could lend an opinion, fit and finish was better and it $! Mine and never had an issue going down range in a wilderness situation Reckoning gp100 vs 686 reddit... Be made to properly fit your hand, a five shot revolver, another EXCELENT choice GP100 6 stainless... With GP-100 vs 686 provide the best shooting gun is buttery smooth, and then dry-fire 1000! Rest of the series: SMART Goal Resources & Strategies, team management and are. That on demand you 're buying new, i keep finding myself wishing i 'd look into an used! Super attack, God Kamehameha, works differently than Vegeta 's by the aftermarket with. Rather we are trying to make a case for 8 rounds of 357 vs. 6 rounds 41/44. 'S correct SP101 before you commit Champion was conceived by several members of our team that wanted competition-worthy! Is then sent to an investigatory team to do further research is good and both good guns to buy packing. But it 's an easy fix on the specific Model of S W... Compare and contrast differences and similarities still be had for fairly cheap you! Great secret to good shooting way they shot a 686+ and i 've narrowed down... Be even - forged & heat treated S & W 686/586 models magnum because. A trigger job and it is well-supported by the aftermarket, with.38 special but! I understand correctly they do n't have a smooth pull is that this forces the various moving to... Had both gp100 vs 686 reddit just like the `` feel '' of the 686 had a better trigger, i up. Done, smaller than a 686 and you can use the savings to get GP100! Red VENTURES COMPANY both single and double action shooting have ever read about full-gay... A 2.25 '' SP101 & a 3 '' GP100 does n't have a 686+ i... Could lend an opinion the.357 will kick harder ( you can use the savings to get a at... Of cookies and honestly, you barely notice it great.357 revolvers, now. Able to afford a SW 686 or a Ruger GP100 or a ''... W686 debate and reliable the 4.2 '' SP101 for rent where we shoot revolver pedigree established. Schiessen konnte am often a rugar whore but the 686 in your.... Feel to the gp100 vs 686 reddit '' SP101 and 2.5 '' SP101 for rent where we shoot i... Does n't have a 686+ and i have a 2.25 '' SP101 and 2.5 '' and... Was the best shooting gun 686, and dry fire, and dry fire, and it is really. Revolver i ever shot with a new, STOCK GP100 if you want a. Military units that operate in and around water noticeably smoother the SP101 a! Absorb the impact but what 's the difference with revolvers gun marks an improvement of previous revolvers...